Skip to main content

'The Loser Letters': The Kingdom of God for the Millennials

The Loser Letters: The Kingdom of God for the Millennials

- Anand Nair

Drawing on CS Lewis' classic The Screwtape Letters for its structure, Mary Eberdstadt's The Loser Letters is young adult-fiction in the epistolary format. The protagonist AF Christian is a young woman who has lost her faith and has become a card-carrying atheist, and is now writing letters to the icons of the New Atheist movement so as to correct their fallacies and inadequacies in argument, so as to strengthen the atheist movement. 

Drawing on a wide variety of arguments, with sources as wide ranging as Thomas Aquinas and Alvin Plantinga, Eberdstadt makes the theistic argument accessible in the millennial lingo, with her characteristic wit and snark. In showing how ideology permeates the modern lifestyle of unbridled hedonism, materialism and radical individuality (things which are taken as axiomatic now in our culture), Eberstadt has drawn an intellectual map of sorts starting from the Protestant reformation in showing how today's youth are left in an overbearing void left by the inability of culture to acknowledge the truth of God and the spiritual and moral responsibilities it is inextricably tied with, leaving them in a helter-skelter life so as to anesthetize oneself from this void. 

Eberdstadt's A.F. is also given an intellectual dignity in that she follows where her arguments lead, i.e. she lives life exactly by the perverted Epicureanism that materialism eventuates at. In this it differs radically from other young adult fiction, in that it shows the protagonist facing drastic consequences for her actions and irreparable damage because of her moral failings, unlike other young adult fiction which asks protagonist to 'live it up' and 'live unapologetically and on their own terms', all of which are a direct inheritance of the individual worship inherited from the thought of the romantics. 

As the plot progresses, AF realizes the objective existence of vices and virtues, and the implausibility of defending such a view without referring to a lawgiver. In this there is a turn to a sort-of Felix culpa (grace by fall) and we are led to a Kafkaesque building where the unintelligibleness leads to a profound realization (analogically similar to how Pascal intended to demonstrate God's existence). 

In a genre which more often that not is lost in a morass of addictive pleasures, which finds itself attracted to the endless possibilities and vices which youth affords (and which the wise know better to avoid), and which seems to eulogize the culture which is precisely the cause of many of the problems of its inhabitants, Eberdstadt doesn't give in to the cosmic pessimism of a Leon Bly, but rather offers a normative and hopeful alternative to build towards the Kingdom of God for the millennial generation, without which as Henri De Lubac pointed out 'all other kingdoms are sure to perish'.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Review of "The Tale of the Rose" by Emma Donaghue

 A Review of "The Tale of the Rose" by Emma Donaghue - Mayura Bhandari “The Tale of The Rose” is a retelling of the popular children’s fairy tale, “The Beauty and The Beast”. It is one of the short stories in the collection by Emma Donoghue, called Kissing The Witch . The story is narrated from the point of a young woman who describes herself as having an appetite for magic. She doesn’t desire suitors, finery or riches. When her father’s ships get lost at sea, her cushy life disappears. But without despair, she gets to work. She washes her father’s clothes, finding peace and satisfaction in it. When fortune smiles upon their family, her siblings ask for riches and finery, but she desires a red rose bud. Her father returns and hands her the rose, explaining that the price of that flower was that he had sold her to a Beast. Obediently, she heads over to the castle, nervous and excited for a new chapter in her life. She recalls the lore the villagers told her. About a young ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Psychological Analysis Of Waiting For Godot

Psychological criticism adopts the methods of "Reading" employed by Freud and later theorists to interpret texts. It argues that literary texts, like dreams, express the secret unconscious desires and anxieties of the author, that a literary work is a manifestation of the author's own neuroses. Here, we are going to apply the same form of criticism on Samuel Beckett’s play, ‘Waiting for Godot.’  Unanswered questions behind the characters behaviour are answered here. We would be looking further to the psychoanalytical approach, Sigmund Freud being the important proponent here. A major focus on the language and how dreams reflect our mental personality are given in his second essay, “Interpretation of Dreams.” The plot clearly states that Estragon has nightmares and Vladimir never addresses them and remains unhelpful towards it, being the one who is aware about their sufferings. The nightmares contain flashbacks and images of a gruesome and horrific event that has hap...
1 comment
Read more

Marxism in Waiting for Godot

Samuel Beckett, the most eminent Irish playwright wrote ‘’Waiting for Godot’’ in French in 1949 and then translated it into English in 1954. This play has been performed as a drama of the absurd with astonishing success in Europe, America and the rest of the world in the post second world war era. For this reason, Martin Esslin calls it, “One of the successes of the post-war theatre” (Esslin, Martin, 1980) In this play, the two tramps, Vladimir and Estragon, wait expectantly to see a man simply known as Godot, a character who does not make an appearance in the play, despite being the titular character. The play begins with waiting for Godot and ends with waiting for Godot. Marxism refers to the political and economic theories of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, later developed by their followers to form the basis of communism. Marxism introduced ideas such as Dialectical Materialism, Alienation, and Economic Determination. Beckett’s ‘Waiting for Godot’ has a minimalist setting...
Post a Comment
Read more